New York Pizza

About

Pizza

Price Range : $11-30 ($$)

  • star
    Yelp rating
    4 stars

Location

Adress: 400 E Valley Rd City Market Plaza, El Jebel, CO 81623

Phone: (970) 963-6088

Business info

  • list_alt
    Takes Reservations
    No
  • directions_car
    Delivery
    Yes
  • move_to_inbox
    Take-out
    Yes
  • credit_card
    Accepts Credit Cards
    No
  • directions_bike
    Bike Parking
    Yes
  • accessibility
    Good for Kids
    Yes
  • group
    Good for Groups
    Yes
  • volume_up
    Noise Level
    Loud
  • local_bar
    Alcohol
    Beer & Wine Only
  • transit_enterexit
    Outdoor Seating
    Yes
  • wifi
    Wi-Fi
    No
  • tv
    Has TV
    Yes
  • fastfood
    Caters
    Yes

Reviews

  • Ylice G.

    star star star star star 3 November 2026

    Ever slice from Basalt to Aspen ... dead on delicious!

  • Katherine D.

    star star star star star 25 October 2026

    Local -Fun- best part...GREAT PIZZA & WINGS!!
    Best value in town and you can tell the lines are clean  on the drafts! Love this place for family meet-ups!

  • Maria M.

    star star star star star 20 October 2026

    This was our favorite spot to have some pizza and wings. Pizza slice is huge and the wings were tasty. Service was friendly & very polite. When we come to Colorado again we will be sure to stop by and eat here again.

  • Rich P.

    star star star star star 12 October 2026

    Always my go to choice for good food and good atmosphere.  Staff is real friendly. Slice and a beer always goes well but recommend a calzone. Also the pizza is real good too.  Even got my leftovers to go wrapped as a swan.  If that doesn't say class I don't know what does.

  • Ashley W.

    star star_border star_border star_border star_border 12 October 2026

    Incredibly disappointed in the management of this restaurant. My husband and I ordered a pizza 15 minutes after the rest of my family and got our 35 minutes before them. They waited over an hour for pizza and when I asked if we could get a discount or refund for the wait the manager (with a multi-colored headband) was incredibly rude and snapped back at me. The ONLY good thing about this place was the cook named Chad. He was incredibly gracious and kind throughout the whole ordeal and should be the manager because he carries himself with a level headed maturity unlike the manager and even rushed to assure us he would personally bring the pizzas over. He acknowledged the mistake when the manager completely lied about it.

People Recommend